At the height of the global financial crisis, a worrying trend emerged among governments at home and abroad, with responses to the problem focusing on greater intervention and regulation.
Facing the worst global downturn since the Great Depression, there was a tendency for key decision makers to overlook the unprecedented benefits that the free enterprise system has delivered over the past three decades. Some policymakers have gone so far as to say that the system has failed and that the only way forward is for government to play a greater role in the economy.
CCI is an organisation with a long standing, rich and proud history of supporting free enterprise. As we move to recovery, CCI believes that now is the time to reinforce the benefits of a market based system, through its soon to be released discussion paper, In Support of Free Enterprise. This discussion paper reaffirms the gains that can be achieved from a free enterprise economy and sets out the reform agenda of wider and deeper economic liberalisation.
A free enterprise system is based upon secure property rights, freedom of contract, and a sound and enforceable legal framework. Clearly, those countries which have embraced these underlying principles have recorded the highest rates of economic growth and human development and generally have better access to education, healthcare and food. Free enterprise is the only economic system which has delivered unprecedented economic growth and prosperity, lifted millions out of poverty and delivered improved living standards for more people worldwide than at any other time in human history.
The economic downturn arising from the global financial crisis in no way diminishes these substantial gains which free enterprise has delivered around the world.
This does not mean that there is no role for government in a free enterprise economy. There is a clear need for government to support the underlying framework of the system, by shaping a fair and secure environment, protecting private property rights and the value of money, enforcing contracts and promoting competition.
However, there is no role for government to increase wealth and living standards by directing economic activity.
These outcomes can only be achieved by the private sector. Free enterprise provides incentives for those who work hard and take risks and encourages entrepreneurship, innovation and consumer choice. This ensures that scarce resources are continually employed in a manner which most effectively matches the changing needs and wants of society and in turn generates wealth and leads to higher standards of living.
In responding to the economic downturn, it is important that governments understand the key causes of the global financial crisis, to ensure that any policy changes will address the underlying problem.
In Australia, the push for greater government involvement in the economy cannot be justified on the basis that a lack of intervention and regulation contributed to the global financial crisis. Australia’s banking sector has largely avoided the toxic assets which have seen the failure of financial institutions worldwide, while the economy has remained relatively resilient in the face of the worst downturn since the Great Depression.
With no evidence of a widespread market failure, the Government should instead continue on an agenda of free market reform, to ensure transparency and improve the economy’s productivity and flexibility.
At an international level, reform to trade barriers will deliver significant benefits by allowing economies to use their resources more effectively and encouraging competition and improved productivity.
Governments around the world must also ensure that market based measures are adopted to address climate change. Given that climate change is a global problem which must be addressed at all levels of government, and by the international community, a global, market-based system would be the most efficient way to reduce carbon emissions, without penalising any specific industry or country.
Nationally, the Government needs to maintain appropriate broad economic settings, particularly in fiscal and monetary policy, which do not stifle enterprise, investment and growth.
There is also considerable scope to strengthen and streamline the national and state taxation regimes, to promote an economic environment that creates employment, income and wealth. However, this will require assessing the Commonwealth and State taxation system as one regime, as the ability to reform the most inefficient state taxes is limited by the imbalance in taxing powers between the Commonwealth and the States.
The Australian industrial relations regime should also be reformed, to support workplaces to effectively deal with constantly changing national and global economy circumstances. Industrial relations reform is essential in promoting economic prosperity and driving productivity in the private sector and should encourage changes in the structure of industries to capitalise on opportunities created by new markets, processes and technologies.
The Government should also continue an agenda of microeconomic reform, to further improve the efficiency and productivity of the Australian economy. The free market reforms which were undertaken over the past three decades have provided the impetus for sustained economic growth as well as historically low unemployment and have been critical to the Australian economy’s ability to respond to changing economic conditions.
In particular, the microeconomic reform agenda should focus on:
• improving competition, by implementing the National Reform Agenda, and introducing further reform in the areas of transport, energy, infrastructure regulation and planning;
• regulatory reform, to reduce the burden on business and improve government and economic performance;
• improving the efficiency and operation of the public sector, to ensure expenditure growth is maintained, service delivery is enhanced and public finances are protected; and
• supporting the development of human capital, through education and training.
There are certainly lessons to be learned from the global financial crisis and undoubtedly this will not be the last crisis facing the global economy. However, the answer is not a bigger role for government. In fact, it is the opposite. The free enterprise system allows economies to adapt, respond and innovate in response to such events. It is important that we do not lose sight of this.